| 2009 Mid-Buckeye Conference Standings |
| Football |
| Fredericktown | 7 | - | 0 |
| Utica | 6 | - | 1 |
| Loudonville | 5 | - | 2 |
| Johnstown | 4 | - | 3 |
| East Knox | 2 | - | 5 |
| Centerburg | 2 | - | 5 |
| Danville | 2 | - | 5 |
| Northridge | 0 | - | 7 |
| Week 4 - Sep 18 | Week 5 - Sep 25 | Week 6 - Oct 2 |
| Johnstown 48, Centerburg 19 |
East Knox 33, Centerburg 7 |
Utica 18, Loudonville 15 |
| Utica 55, East Knox 13 |
Utica 56, Northridge 17 |
Fredericktown 47, Johnstown 22 |
| Fredericktown 64, Northridge 7 | Loudonville 22, Johnstown 0 |
East Knox 35, Northridge 34 |
| Loudonville 35, Danville 7 |
Fredericktown 51, Danville 6 |
Centerburg 24, Danville 21 |
| Week 7 - Oct 9 | Week 8 - Oct 16 | Week 9 - Oct 23 |
| Utica 48, Johnstown 20 |
Centerburg 39, Northridge 12 |
Loudonville 64, Northridge 7 |
| Fredericktown 47, East Knox 0 |
Johnstown 13, Danville 6 |
Fredericktown 34, Centerburg 6 |
| Danville 41, Northridge 0 |
Loudonville 54, East Knox 0 |
Johnstown 17, East Knox 0 |
| Loudonville 28, Centerburg 7 |
Fredericktown 27, Utica 12 |
Utica 27, Danville 0 |
| Week 10 - Oct 30 |
| Utica 14, Centerburg 13 |
| Fredericktown 31, Loudonville 28 |
| Johnstown 62, Northridge 8 |
| Danville
12, East Knox 7 |